There seems to be a battle among music lovers over what country music is, and where it should go. On one hand are the Nashville Music Row types who follow the Clear Channel market, chasing whatever the latest thing that worked and repeating it ad nauseum. Gretchen Wilson is the thing? Great - let's get tons of odes to being a stupid hillbilly redneck smalltown bumfuck. Let's get Big & Rich to write Faith Hill a tune about being backwater all this time - maybe people will then forget that she was a Loreal model and that her last album cast her as being an uptown elite - not that anyone noticed anyway, given its sales.
On the other hand, you have No Depression elitists - they're the new breed of college educated, upper income urban dwellers, that supplanted the folk movement of the 60's with today's alt-country/Americana, snobbish music fans who think they are the true descendants of the Carter Family brought to earth to wrest country music away from Nashville. They worship at the altar of Gram Parsons, and all the bands that Uncle Tupelo has wrought. Whiskeytown, The Waco Brothers, and the entire Bloodshot Records label travel down this road.
Both camps attempt to claim Hank, Johnny and Willie as their own, and both have merit. But while these two groups have been racing in parallel to see where to take (and how far they can separate) Country music, prominent artists from each camp have been looking backward, offering their take on what it used to be, with interesting results.


Martina McBride, one of the most prominent female singers in Nashville the past decade, just release Timeless, a collection of interpretations of some of country's greatest from mostly the 60's and 70's. Ryan Adams, an artist the alt-country faithful wish would come back to the fold, issued Jacksonville City Nights, a collection of originals based on his idea of what country music from that same era sounded like.
Martina's version of country is actually wildly different than the version she typically records. So much so that she even cast aside her producer, and recorded it herself (he adds liner notes and is thanked in the credits). She only used vintage instruments and mics, went with less instrumentation than normal and sang in a much more restrained manner. The thought that went into this resulted in easily her best sounding record ever. Her song selection is impeccable, pulling out chestnuts from Ernest Tubb, Jeannie Pruett and Sammi Smith - artists that most young'uns don't even know, and giving them new life. And Martina often uses the same phrasing and cadence when singing the songs, chopping syllables when she might have stretched it out on a new song - this was particularly noticed and appreciated on her equally heartbreaking run through Connie Smith's Once a Day. Sometimes the emotion falls flat in her singing, but it's a minor quibble with such a massive and successful undertaking.
Ryan Adams second release of 2005, Jacksonville is a more concise and entertaining effort than his earlier, and still quite good Cold Roses. It's also his second album with his backing band The Cardinals, and they are proving to be as adept at mimicing musical genres as he is at writing to them. They honky tonk their piano runs, there's tons of steel geetar, and the mood just feels old. The cover art also does a great job at imitating the album covers of that era (much the same way the new Faith Hill video imitates the styles and Lee Ann Womack styled her album cover).

However, his songs aren't as immediately catchy as on Timeless. This doesn't mean they aren't good, however, as "A Kiss Before I Go" is a fantastic drinking song, and "My Heart Is Broken" has a timeless feel to its balladry. It would be hard to compare his songs on this record to those of Timeless, as those were songs written my many of the greatest writers of any genre.
And the winner? Country music fans. They are getting some first-rate music from artists trying to expand their boundaries by looking backward, and find that the past is rich resource. For Nashville, it is a way to celebrate the legacy in a classy manner often forgotten by many of the hamhanded guys out there. For Americana, it's a way of remembering that Nashville is Music City USA for a reason - the sounds they created there were the template.